Under Trump, Social Security resumes what it once called ‘clawback cruelty’
By David Hilzenrath, Jodie Fleischer, Cox Media Group, KFF Health News
A year ago, a new head of Social Security set out to stop the agency from financially devastating many of the people it was meant to help.
The agency had long made it a practice to reduce or halt benefit checks to recoup billions of dollars in payments it sent recipients but later said they never should have received.
Martin O’Malley, then the Social Security Administration commissioner, announced in March 2024 the agency would no longer cut off people’s monthly old-age, survivors, and disability checks to recoup money they had allegedly been overpaid — a pattern he called “clawback cruelty.” Instead, it would default to withholding 10% of monthly benefits. The new policy allowed people who already live on little to pay their rent and keep food on the table.
Last Friday, the Trump administration reversed that policy.
Beginning March 27, to recover new overpayments, the Social Security Administration will automatically withhold 100% of recipients’ monthly benefits, the agency announced.