Are lower insurance rates reducing homeowners’ costs? We shopped four policies to find out
Are lower home insurance rates leading to cost reductions for Florida homeowners?
After insurance leaders in Florida spent the last year touting the revival of a healthy insurance market, the South Florida Sun Sentinel decided to find out whether policyholders have been affected in the only way most of us care about: Can we insure our homes for a lower price?
Insurers say the only way to find out is to shop your policy out on the open market.
So for this test, the Sun Sentinel recruited four homeowners — two each in south and central Florida — and four agents.
Each agent obtained quotes for two homeowners from insurance companies they are contracted to represent.
The results:
— Among 13 private-market insurers that provided quotes, only two — Edison and newcomer Ovation — offered to reduce premiums. Edison and Ovation both offered lower premiums to one of four participating homeowners while Ovation also offered a lower cost to another homeowner.
— Many of the quotes included $10,000 caps on water damage coverage and several capped roof coverage at the actual cash value, rather than replacement cost. These caps stem from insurers’ experience with high volumes of roof and water claims and heavy litigation connected to them.